The Way I Make It Is

The End of Pay Secrecy?

The End of Pay Secrecy?

The End of Pay Secrecy? - What the EU Pay Transparency Directive Means for Jobseekers, Employees & Employers in Ireland

The EU Pay Transparency Directive officially entered into force on June 2023. The deadline for member states to transpose it into national law was June 7, 2026. Ireland has missed this deadline. I think this is because of the complexity involved and because other issues have taken priority. Hopefully they will give greater priority to transposing these provisions as they really represent welcome changes for workers in Ireland.

But despite the Directive meeting a legislative bottleneck, its effects are already being felt by workers and jobseekers in Ireland, as employers get ready for the new requirements.

The Core Aim & Provisions of the EU Pay Transparency Directive

The Directive’s core aim is to eliminate the persistent gender pay gap. But the rights it affords offer real benefits to all. The obligations it places on employers apply to all public and private sector employers, regardless of company size. There are requirements to report employees pay, which apply only to companies of a certain size, and these are being implemented on a phased basis. Eventually employers with 100 or more employees will be required to produce these reports.

The EU Transparency Directive introduces rules to ensure that “equal work or work of equal value” is compensated equally, regardless of gender. But its effect is really to introduce transparency into what you can expect to be paid and what you should be paid in your role. The main provisions include:

  • Pre-Employment Transparency: Employers must state a starting salary or clear pay range in job listings or before the first interview. So we should see no more job listings that just state “Competitive” under Salary.
  • The Salary History Ban: Companies are strictly prohibited from asking candidates what they made in their previous roles.
  • The Right to Information: Staff members gain the legal right to request data on the average pay levels of colleagues doing the same job, broken down by sex. To be clear, this doesn’t mean that you can find out from HR exactly what your colleagues earn, but you can request what is the average pay in your company for the work you do.
  • Banning Pay Secrecy: Employment contracts can no longer contain clauses forbidding coworkers from discussing their compensation.
  • Shifting the Burden of Proof: If a worker brings a pay discrimination claim, the employer must prove they did not discriminate, rather than the employee proving that they did.

How Pay Transparency Affects Employees and Jobseekers in Ireland

For workers and jobseekers, this Directive is a game-changer for wage bargaining and pay equity.

  • Jobseekers Will No Longer Devalue Their Work: Jobseekers no longer have to endure the “What are your salary expectations?” guessing game. Because salary ranges or indicative pay rates must be disclosed upfront, applicants can avoid wasting time on underpaid roles.
  • Breaking the Cycle of Being Underpaid: Questions about your previous salary are banned, so the Directive prevents your previous low wage from following you from job to job.
  • No Pay Secrecy: Existing employees can find out what other employees doing the same sort of work as them are paid on average. And pay-secrecy clauses in employment contracts are no longer enforceable. - No, you won’t be able to see or demand a specific colleague’s payslip, and they won’t see yours, but you will have the right to know what the gender-disaggregated average salary for your exact role is.

How Pay Transparency Affects Employers in Ireland

Ireland already passed the Gender Pay Gap Information Act in 2021, which requires Irish employers with 50+ staff to publish basic gender pay gap reports annually. But the Directive layers significant new obligations on top of that framework.

To ensure compliance with the Directive, employers should -

  • Audit Hiring Processes: Review all job listings to ensure a salary band or indicative pay range is shown to candidates before they apply for the role. The Directive doesn’t require that pay is indicated in job advertisements but it does mandate that employers disclose the initial pay range or level before the first interview, and most jobseekers now skip listings that don’t include pay details. Remove questions regarding salary expectations and pay history from job listings, application forms, interview scripts, and any briefing packs used by third-party recruiters.
  • Check Existing Employment Contracts: Check employees contracts for pay-secrecy clauses, as these are no longer be enforceable.
  • Set Up Pay Transparency Procedures: Establish a process for employees to request pay information, allowing them to receive written details of their own pay level and the average pay of colleagues doing the same or equivalent work, disaggregated by gender.
  • Create the Required Data Infrastructure to handle Employee Requests & Reporting Obligations Employers must be able to report by category of worker, gender, all pay components (including benefit-in-kind and bonuses), and progression criteria

Note: Under the Directive, if an employer’s pay gap reporting reveals an unjustified gap of 5% or higher in any category of workers, and they fail to remedy the situation within 6 months, the employer is then legally bound to conduct a formal joint pay assessment with worker representatives and implement immediate corrective measures.

What Might be Considered a Justified Pay Gap?

Under the Directive, an employer cannot simply say, “We pay them more because they negotiated better,” or “That’s just what the market dictates.”

Instead, if you discover a peer of the opposite sex is earning more than you for work of equal value, the employer must legally prove the difference is based on objective, gender-neutral criteria.

Employers can legally justify a pay discrepancy using the following reasons:

  1. Measurable Professional Experience (Seniority)

    An employer may pay a worker more if they have a proven track record or a higher number of relevant years in the industry.

    The experience must directly benefit the execution of the job duties. Simply having generic years working in the industry may not count.

  2. Advanced Qualifications and Certifications

    If a colleague possesses a higher level of formal education, specialized degrees, or professional certifications that are highly relevant to the role, a higher salary is justified.

    Example: Two engineers do the same daily work, but one holds a specialized certification or qualification required for signing off on specific projects.

  3. Job Performance and Merit

    Pay differences driven by performance-related metrics, individual KPIs, or structured merit-based bonuses are entirely legal.

    The performance evaluation system must be completely transparent, documented, and applied to all employees equally without bias.

  4. Job Scarcity and “Hard-to-Fill” Skills

    While standard “market rate” arguments are highly scrutinized under the Directive, employers can justify higher pay if a specific employee possesses an exceptionally scarce skill-set or a niche technical competence that is highly sought after in the market.

  5. Working Conditions and Shift Premiums

    If a colleague’s role subjects them to tougher physical or environmental constraints, their premium pay is legally sound.

    Examples: Working anti-social hours (night shifts or weekend rotations), regular mandatory travel, or working in hazardous or high-stress conditions.

  6. Geographic Cost of Living

    If you and your colleague work for the same Irish company but you live in a rural area while they are permanently contracted to a high-cost hub like Dublin, the employer can legally factor in a localised cost-of-living adjustment.

What Employers Can’t Use as an Excuse

The Directive explicitly closes loopholes that companies used to rely on. The following justifications are now illegal:

  • “They asked for more in the interview” - Negotiation skills are no longer an objective justification for unequal pay.
  • “They used to make more at their old job” - Since wage history questions are banned, past high wages cannot be used to justify a current high wage.
  • “It’s a different job title” - The Directive uses the legal concept “categories of workers performing the same work or work of equal value”. It mandates that these worker categories be built on objective, gender-neutral criteria: skills, effort required, responsibility, and working conditions. If workers fall under the same category and are doing the same job or a job of equal value, then the titles are irrelevant.

These are Welcome Changes

The provisions in this EU Directive bring in really positive and welcome changes. Remember, it doesn’t require individuals to disclose anything to colleagues, but it does let workers know what the average pay is in the company for someone doing their type of work. And if they are being paid less than other people, and some of those people are of the opposite sex, then they have a case for having their wages increased in line with what others are being paid. And it’s not like there aren’t reasonable justifications employers can make regarding pay differences. These provisions ensure that there must be a genuine business case for any differences in pay. And isn’t that how it should be?

Hopefully, Ireland won’t be too long in fully transposing it into Irish law. Only five EU countries have done so to date; Italy, Lithuania, Malta, Slovakia and Greece.

This is good. Ireland has shown an interest in addressing Pay Gaps with the 2021 Act. So let’s get this done.

More On This

screenshot of article
ICTU - delays ‘unacceptable’
screenshot of article
Most Employers Not Ready
screenshot of article
Complete Guide for Employers
screenshot of article
Practical Guide for Irish Employers
About twimii
Rabbit, Twimii, Ted and Cow

About Twimii & the gang

Who is Twimii? What´s the deal with the toys? Are the recipes really made by a fluffy cow?

Latest Bits & Pieces
cup of coffee and pen on an open copybook that reads Rip it up and start again
I made some changes

Twimii has undergone a little renovation. Let me take you on a tour.

Bicycles & Accidents

Are you covered?

Earth Calling Planet 9

A search for a Planet 9

Some Hallowe’en Related Deepdives

Pumpkins, Hallowe’en customs, and the Pied Piper

Popular Bits & Pieces
Don’t Remove the Triple Lock

Give us a Referendum

Israel Must Change Course

While it is in its power to do so

Hind Rajab
The Voice of Hind Rajab

A child crying out for rescue

Popular Posts
tinned mackeral and tomato rice
Tinned Mackerel & Tomato Rice

One pot meal that´s as quick and easy as it is tasty and healthy

marrowfat pea soup with a swirl of creme fraiche and cracked black pepper
Marrowfat Pea Soup

So simple & tasty — perfect for the colder weather

Fig Orange & Almond Rolls

A healthy & sweet vegan treat

Peter and Dominique on the Balcony
Part 18 - Take Your Fountainhead …

Party at Enright’s House

twimii, Ted, Rabbit and Cow in Maura's kitchen
Page 1 - Foggy Days

Something awful has occurred

A grass snake
The Grass Snake

A retelling of an Austrian folktale

Don’t Remove the Triple Lock

Give us a Referendum

Israel Must Change Course

While it is in its power to do so

Why are we Changing Citizenship Application Process?

How is this better?